Why Loan Modifications RARELY Happen.
- Jun 24, 2010
- Help for Homeowners
- No Comments
The four largest mortgage lenders in the United States were grilled on Capitol Hill on Thursday about the limited number of home loans they have modified for homeowners facing foreclosure.
My favorite quote was from Ohio Rep. Dennis Kucinich who asked David Lowman, chief executive of home lending at JPMorgan Chase & Co.: “I just wonder how hard you are really trying?”
From one Dennis to another… That’s my opinion too. The lenders are not trying hard enough and the “rules and guidelines” are ridiculous.
Follow this example of Mr & Mrs Homeowner who approach their lender, ABC Bank, to seek a loan modification.
MMH: “We would like to apply for a loan modification”
ABC: “We would love to help you! What is the balance on your current home loan?”
MMH: “$300,000″
ABC: “Well, according to my computer-generated home valuation system, it looks like your home is worth $200,000 today. We can APPROVE YOU FOR A LOAN MODIFICATION of up to 105% of your home’s value at today’s low interest rates!”
MMH: “That sounds great! Where do we sign?”
ABC: “Not so fast… If we give you a new loan at today’s low interest rates for 105% of your home’s value, the new loan will be for $210,000 and that will leave you $90,000 short of what you need to pay off your existing loan… so…. you will need to bring us a 1-time payment of $90,000 and THEN we will modify your loan! Are you ready to sign now?”
MMH: “What? If I had $90,000, I would not need a loan modification!”
Yes my friends, that is how loan modifications work. Or should I say… that’s why they don’t work.
In a federal report released last week, as few as 0.1 percent of mortgage modifications initiated under the new foreclosure prevention program involve reductions of principal.
In my opinion, until principal-balance-reductions become a required part of loan modifications, the nation will continue to hover around the embarrassingly low 6.0% completion rate of loans that are successfully modified.
As I see it, the only people that are able to get a loan modification today are those who are not seriously upside-down on their home or are struggling with an exceptionally high interest rate (above 10%).
Houston…we still have a problem!
